I keep seeing a lot of people posting the following status update on Facebook:
“Thank you Florida, Kentucky, and Missouri, which are the first states that will require drug testing when applying for welfare. Some people are crying and calling this unconstitutional. How is this unconstitutional? It’s OK to drug test people who WORK for their money but not those who don’t?… Re-post this if you’d like to see this done in all 50 states!”
Sounds pretty awesome, right?! You work your tail off for peanuts and people who don’t shouldn’t get a free ride, should they?! This is America! Make your own way and get a job, you lazy bum!
Maybe it sounds good as a knee jerk reaction. Maybe you haven’t thought it through. Well, considering I’m unemployed, and don’t drink and don’t smoke and don’t do drugs, let me take the side of those in a less fortunate situation. And I DEFY you to say that I am lazy and haven’t earned my way and contributed to society. I made TV shows and you watched them, so if anything, you’re the couch potato.
First off, each welfare applicant has their own unique set of circumstances at the root of their misfortune, so therefore no broad legislation could right the wrongs of the system. I believe this means that we should, for the time being, accept the shortcomings of the current system and focus our efforts in more effective areas.
Let’s not stop there. If you’re so into drug testing for these lazy good-for-nothing welfare users who are taking advantage of all your hard work, let’s take it further. Shouldn’t all types of public assistance require drug testing? How would you feel if testing was required for unemployment benefits or social security? How about those on disability or the parents of Head Start children? Should they be tested as well? What about students receiving financial aid, or WIC mothers, or seniors on Medicaid? Clearly these people could also be abusing the generosity of the American public.
LET’S BE THOROUGH.
You also might not be considering this, but the bank and auto industry bailouts are estimated to be somewhere between 770 billion and 1.2 trillion. We’re talking tax cuts, grossly profitable contracts, and outright cash payments to big businesses that take that money and a lot of the jobs at those companies and take them overseas.
All that bailout money could have paid the last decade of social welfare and not even one CEO or politician was drug tested. Plus, urinalysis is the only semi-affordable way to drug test on such a large scale and there are a handful ways you can beat that already highly ineffective test. Also, if you think the cost of the drug testing isn’t going to come out of your tax dollars, you are beyond naive.
People applying for state jobs have to pay around 90 bucks out of pocket for this test. Do the math of that cost times however many people are on welfare!
It’s time to come to the realization that salvation doesn’t lie in reforming our tiny offerings to the poor, but by taking back the money that was swindled from us by the wealthy. Even Warren Buffet agrees with it, as he wrote an op-ed piece last week in the NY Times telling the Government to tax the rich more and take away the tax cuts. The richest 1% of our nation possesses more wealth than the poorest 90% and this gap is growing every day.
Wake the hell up, America, and put your vitriol towards the real issues.
EDIT – 8/21/11: Jon Stewart from the Daily Show pretty much took what I said and ran with it to hilarious effect. Do enjoy.
The Daily Show – World of Class Warfare – The Poor’s Free Ride Is Over
Get More: Daily Show Full Episodes,Political Humor & Satire Blog,The Daily Show on Facebook